Why Memorize Math Facts?
Aimee Yermish, Educational Consultant
My private practice is full of kids whose parents thought
that way, and now have to pay me lots of money to teach the kids what
they could have been taught for free in second or third grade. They
usually hit the wall some time in middle school or in algebra I, where
you have to use these math facts rapidly on the fly.
Quick! Two numbers that multiply to -24 and sum to 5!
No, sorry, using a calculator to do guess-and-check to factor a quadratic
equation is not an efficient strategy. And inefficient rather rapidly blends
into ineffective, because when it takes you too long and uses too much working
memory to do the basic skills, you can't keep track of the higher skills you're
supposed to be learning in your current grade. It's like a dyslexic kid who
can't keep track of the flow of ideas in a long article because he's spending
too much brain power (and hence time) on reading individual words. It may seem
like it only takes a few seconds to punch "6x4" into the calculator, but it
really does add up and derail the kid's train of thought.
Calculators are useful tools, but they need to be used for the right
kinds of tasks. They should never be used to substitute for learning
the skill that is actually being taught. Kids need to be independent
enough that they can choose their brain over the calculator as the most
effective tool for the job, as it frequently is, and so that, as
Marjorie points out, they will be estimating the answers on the fly so
that they can realize when they may have made calculator mistakes.
"If you don't know the math, will you know that you
pressed the wrong buttons?
My chemistry professor used to have a saying, "Don't
be a Calculator Cripple."" -- Marjorie
I usually express that as "Freitag's Law" (named after my friend Walt
Freitag who was the first to say it in my hearing) "Never use a tool
that's smarter than you are."
And while I would agree that some of the very highest areas of math
(beyond my own expertise, as I am but a lowly molecular
biologist-turned-educator, so I haven't studied much beyond multivariate
calculus and simple differential equations, plus statistics, linear
algebra, and discrete math) do not require automaticity of basic math
facts, they do require automaticity of the skills that fall somewhere in
between them and single-digit addition, and that those skills are very
difficult to master and to automatize when the basic stuff isn't firmly
in place. It's going to be very difficult to get to graduate-level
mathematics if you can't hack calculus because you couldn't hack algebra
because you couldn't hack middle-school math because you couldn't hack
Now, where you do have my agreement is that a gifted child who is
ready to progress should be allowed to progress. If he is ready to
understand algebra, then he should be allowed to study algebra, even if
he is still struggling to memorize his math facts. The two areas should
be worked on in parallel. Frequently, it's the algebra study that
convinces the kids that it was a good idea to learn the math facts in
the first place. Holding the "good stuff" hostage to the gifted kid's
weakness with basic facts is really neither fair nor truly appropriate,
and it's a recipe for underachievement.
I think there's a basic problem here that we as the parents of gifted
children must come to terms with. Not all useful learning is
intrinsically interesting. Our kids have a right not to be bored in
that they should not be held down, but they do not have a right not to
be bored such that they have a right to skip anything that isn't fun to
learn. Math facts are boring. Absolutely. But that doesn't mean that
our precious children who don't tolerate boredom well shouldn't have to
learn them. We have to teach our kids the difference between being
bored because you are being taught something you have already mastered
and being bored because the work is intrinsically boring but still
important. We can turn our fertile brains towards making the practice
fun and interesting, if we don't tolerate boredom well, but we don't get
to just declare ourselves to be so brilliant that no one should ever
make us do anything we don't feel like doing.
Another issue that I think we as gifted parents have to come to terms
with here is that our brilliant children may not always be brilliant
across the board. They may in fact not be very good at rapid retrieval
of decontextualized information like math facts. That skill may not
come easily to them. Frequently, when someone asks this question on
this board, it's because their kid is bombing the mad minutes and
freaking out and calling themselves stupid, and the parent wants to tell
the teacher not to make their kid do the timed practice. But that's
completely backwards -- if the kid isn't doing well at the mad minutes,
then that shows that he has something to learn! Wow! Since we're
often complaining that they never teach our kids anything, when they
actually are teaching our kids something, we
should be pleased.
All gifted kids must, at some point in their
lives, recognize that giftedness does not mean that everything comes
easily and that one never needs to work hard at anything. As a parent,
our goal in this kind of situation should be to help
the kid emotionally adjust to the situation and to help him come up with
effective strategies for learning those annoying math facts so that they
don't have to be upsetting any more, not to browbeat the teacher into
not teaching our precious kid something that he is having trouble
learning to the level of automaticity necessary for future success in
mathematics. We, of all people, should not lower our expectations of
our children just because they meet with initial difficulty.
"Why stop there?
Let's make them memorize Latin roots if holding large
chunks of useful data in ones memory is good."
Actually, that's an excellent idea (I know you meant to be ironic, but
sorry, it didn't work). If you want to improve your vocabulary, then by far the
most efficient route is to memorize Latin and Greek roots.
© 2003 by Aimee Yermish
Reprinted with permission of the author.
printed from Hoagies' Gifted Education Page,
Original URL is www.hoagiesgifted.org/why_memorize.htm